Meet The $1,000,000 Government Employee
GOLDEN, Colo. â The federal governmentâs dream of a renewable energy empire hinges on a scrubby outpost here, where scientists and executives doggedly explore a
National Renewable Energy Laboratory campus
If you live outside Colorado, you probably havenât heard of theÂ National Renewable Energy Laboratory â NRELÂ for short. Itâs the place where solar panels, windmills and corn are deemed the energy source of the future and companies who support such endeavors are courted.
Itâs also the place where highly paid staff decide how to spend hundreds of millions in taxpayer dollars.
And the public pays those decision-makers well: Â NRELâs top executive,Â Dr. Dan Arvizu, makes close to a million dollars per year. His two top lieutenants rake in more than half a million each and nine others make more than $350,000 a year.
But what is really going on there? Energy expertÂ Amy Oliver CookeÂ drove out to the site, which looks something like Nevadaâs Area 51 with its remote location and forbidding concrete buildings. NREL had started a construction project and Cooke wanted to see for herself. She didnât get far: a man in an SUV seemingly appeared out of nowhere, stopped her car, and told her to leave.
âA beefy looking fellow told me, âItâs top secret,â said Cooke, director of theÂ Energy Policy CenterÂ at theIndependence InstituteÂ think tank. âI said, âIâm a taxpayer and I want to see what youâre buildingâ and he said it was it was âtop secret so we can bring Americans a better future.ââ
With its bloated budget and overseen by a $533 million a year government-funded management company, Cooke isnât buying it.
âNREL has given us two of the most significant boondoggles, one of them being ethanol and the other being (bankrupt) Abound Solar,â she said. âThey were part of the team that pushed Abound Solar along. In fact, they wrote in March 2011 on their website how proud they were of their role in abound solar.
âAm I impressed with NREL? No, not really,â she said.
NRELâs taxpayer-funded management company has seen its budget more than double since 2006. Thatâs when one of its most ardent supporters, Rep. Ed Perlmutter D-Lakewood, was first elected to Congress. The lab sits in the middle of his district.
But Perlmutterâs ties go beyond merelypromoting green legislationÂ and lobbying his colleagues for NREL funds. He has received $12,670 in campaign contributions from executives of NREL and its management company, MRIGlobal, a company that describes itself as âan independent, not-for-profit organization that performs contract research for government and industry.â Perlmuterâs father has served as a trusteeÂ for MRI and MRIGlobal during the past decade. Between 2003 and 2005, Perlmutter was also a trustee.Â These positions were unpaid.
Perlmutter did not respond to phone calls seeking comment for this story.
FOLLOWING THE MONEY
Funded by the U.S. Department of Energy, NREL started in 1977 as the Solar Energy Research Institute, a Jimmy Carter-era response to the 1973 Mideast oil crisis. Its budget, then about $100 million, was slashed during the Reagan era.
By the time Perlmutter was elected, NRELâs budget was $209.6 million. It increased steadily before ballooning to $536.5, a beneficiary of President Obamaâs stimulus plan and a $135 million contract spread out over five years to construct a new science center. Its current $352 million budget is down slightly from last yearâs $388.6 million.
From its inception, NREL has been managed by MRIGlobal, back then called the Midwest Research Institute.
To handle lab management, MRIGlobal partnered with Ohio-based Battelle Memorial Institute, which describes itself as âthe worldâs largest nonprofit research and development organization.â The pair formed Alliance for Sustainable Energy, a separate non-profit in 2008, for the sole purpose of managing NREL and installedNRELâs top executivesÂ as its directors.
Despite record federal debt, municipal bankruptcies and a nagging global recession, those executives enjoy pay packages that are out of reach of most Americans who pay their salaries. MRIGlobal and Alliance tax documents obtained by Watchdog show most earned well into six-figures:
- Dan Arvizu, Alliance president and NREL director
- Bobi Garrett, NREL senior vice president of Outreach, Planning and Analysis
- William Glover, NREL deputy lab director and CEO (retired)
- Catherine Porto, NREL senior vice president
The budget to manage Alliance is mind-boggling â and rising. For 2010, tax documents show, Alliance received $532.9 million from the Department of Energy, a whopping $189 million more than they were paid in 2008.
In 2010, MRIGlobalâs tax return shows DOE funding of $104.8 million, while Battelleâs tax return reported $4.55 billion in government grants. Its activities included management of five national laboratories (including NREL) and operating as subcontractor at a sixth.
However, at least one expert who has studied NREL doesnât see any problem with the fact that the agency is overseen by a management company.
âI have no problems with the contractors operating the lab. They would do a much more efficient job than the government,â said Nick Loris, an energy policy analyst with the Heritage Foundation. âIt should lower the cost of these projects.â
But what Loris doesnât like is the entire concept of placing the government in a role of making energy affordable. That should be a job for the private sector.
âItâs not the governmentâs role to make energy cheaper. There is no reason the taxpayer should subsidize this,â he said. âWeâve seen the failures when the government gets involved in these projects. If they are going to be successful in the marketplace, they wouldnât need help from the governmentâ
In fact, the billions that have been siphoned into renewable energy have yet to produce a fraction of the promised return, Cooke claims.
Solar and wind still remain prohibitively expensive and not viable for general use as are corn and wood chips to fuel cars. Yet NREL labs continue to work to this end. Cooke predicts that numerous taxpayer-subsidized companies will go bankrupt in the coming years just as the overinflated housing market came crashing down.